Augur, Machine Zone and The Fallacy of The Fat Protocol

Image for post
Image for post

The Monegro Paper

  • In the Web, all the ultimate value ended up being captured by the top consumer apps: Google, Amazon and Facebook. Protocols like HTTP and HTML made zero money.
  • There are no successful apps in Blockchain. And yet “protocols” such as Bitcoin and Ethereum have made reached hundreds of billions of dollars in market cap.
  • Therefore, all the real value clearly goes to protocols not apps.
  • The reason for this is that apps are free but create demand for tokens from the protocol. Token prices increase and protocol investors win. QED.

Implicitly or explicitly 95% of all crypto investors that I meet seem to buy into this argument. But the argument, while crystal clear and elegant actually is completely false. It’s a page out of Rhinoceros by Eugene Ionesco.

“All cats are mortal. Socrates is mortal. Therefore Socrates is a cat.”

As clever as both syllogisms are, they are both equally flawed.

In the case of cats A → B and C → B does not imply A → C.

In the case of Protocols, it’s even more devious: Bitcoin is not a protocol, and Ethereum only half is.

Bitcoin is not really a protocol

Wrong. The general usage of the word “protocol” generally implies a “base layer” (such as HTTP) on which other things are built. What is built on top of Bitcoin? Nothing. In fact it is more like a single decentralized application than a base layer protocol. More like a decentralized Paypal as opposed to FTP.

Ethereum is hardly a “base layer” either.

So the clever diagram where all these apps are built on top of Bitcoin and Ethereum is a fallacy. There are zero apps built on top of Bitcoin, and at the present time close to zero on Ethereum.

So why is this thinking so dangerous?


Image for post
Image for post

Augur, to me is a poster child for this kind of thinking. In development for 5 years, it’s a betting protocol with exactly zero users, and a market cap of 436 million dollars (as of April 30 2018). Now Augur may end up doing fine, as any app in the app store may end up being the next Spotify, but in playing with the Augur beta as opposed to the early Spotify beta (circa 2009), there are clear usability differences. One is essentially not only not useful, but hard to see why it has any real advantage over other betting platforms such as BetFair (other than it being more difficult to shut down). The other one was pure joy from day 1.

It’s a protocol with nothing on top of it.

Machine Zone

Image for post
Image for post

Machine Zone, on the other hand is also doing an ICO. But Machine Zone is a 550 person game studio with massive hits like Game of War and Mobile Strike. It has products people actually love. It is creating a token which will accrue 100% of the value to Machine Zone and close to zero on HashGraph on which it will build its LIT token.

It’s an app with a token.

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store